Best Natural Mascara

Did you know that your skin absorbs substances faster than your stomach? Yes, the products that you apply on your face get into your system quicker than an apple you ate a few hours ago. That’s why we need to be very careful not only with our food but also with our cosmetic products. Many people around the world have already stopped using famous brand products just because they are full of parabens and chemicals that irritate eyes and face and are bad for your skin.

Under these terms you need to search for the best product that won’t harm you or irritate your eyes but, at the same time, lasts all day and gives you a look you hoped to achieve. Now you can find lots of types of vegan, cruelty-free, no parabens mascara! And all this goes hand in hand with natural and simple looks! We prepared for you not only a list of the best natural looking mascara reviews but also, we answered to some questions that will make your search for the best mascara so much easier: “What is the best natural mascara?”, “What is the best natural mascara to use?”, or “Which is the best mascara with natural ingredients?”

Plants, minerals & oils

When it comes to best mascara with natural ingredients, you need to keep in mind the following advice: Be sure it is all vegan, made only of plants, oils or butter and vitamins and minerals. That won’t make your eyes irritated, and chances for allergies to appear are minimum. For example, castor oil not only that makes your lashes stronger, thicker and helps them grow faster; it also makes them more resistant. Vitamin B is also a natural stimulant for your lashes that you can search on the list of ingredients.

Look natural, feel natural

Now let’s talk about that natural look! Simple is now the new luxury! And if simplicity mixes with healthy and cruelty-free products, the effect will not go unseen. Long, thick and healthy lashes, full of volume will magnetize people around you. Don’t be surprised if people will have many questions about the products you use and how you keep your eyelashes so beautiful and healthy!

 

Top 6 Best Natural Mascara Reviews

W3LL PEOPLE – Expressionist Bio-Extreme Black Mascara

 

 

Packaging: White classy tube

Wand: Plastic, cascade shaped brush

Formula: Natural ingredients mascara, contains beeswax, stearic acid, Brazil wax, carnauba wax, castor oil, glycerin, sunflower seed oil. 100% cruelty-free, petroleum-free, paraben-free, gluten-free, aluminum-free, fiber-free, non-toxic mascara

Performance and Reviews: Raise your hand if your parents gave you castor oil as a child! And you hated it, right? Well, we’re telling you, this time you will fell in love with it. Because of its unique properties, your lashes will grow longer, will be healthier and stronger. Also, this is a non-toxic mascara, all natural organic. The minerals from the formula will create the blackest and luxurious lashes for you. The unique brush design and cascade shaped will give you access to all the lashes from the corners of the eye and their base. You will create a superb, natural and unique look that will seize everyone’s attention. It is perfect for people who wear contact lens or have sensitive eyes because it’s all natural and the effect is everything you wanted. The best thing about this mascara is that it doesn’t clump. You can even try more than two coats, and after the application, you’ll see that nothing will remain around your eyes.

PROS:
  • Separates lashes very well
  • 100% cruelty-free, petroleum-free, paraben-free, gluten-free, coal tar-free, aluminum-free, fiber-free
  • No clumping


 

100% Pure: Fruit Pigmented Mascara Black Tea

 

Packaging: Silver tube with floral motives

Wand: Long wand with slightly curvy brush

Formula: Natural organic ingredients, water resistant, uses fruits pigments to color your lashes, non-toxic mascara

Performance and Reviews: You want a real black color on your lashes? In this case, this mascara was made for you! Because it has black tea natural pigments, you will see a big difference between classic mascaras and the 100% Pure: Fruit Pigmented Mascara Black Tea. Your lashes never had that intense black color that you always craved for. By far, this is the best natural non-clumping mascara! It is ideal for sensitive eyes or people who are allergic to makeup products because this is 100% made of natural ingredients. It is easy to remove and smells very nice, but all the reviews point one thing: if you have oily skin, after wearing it all day you will get this product tends to smudge. And that’s quite embarrassing! Also, many people complained about one ingredient: hydrolyzed wheat protein, an allergen! Otherwise, the product will make your lashes look tremendous, clean and very well defined.

PROS:
  • Not clumping
  • Easy to remove
  • Great smell

CONS:
  • Not good for people with oily skin



Ecco Bella FlowerColor Mascara

 

Packaging: Classy black container with a golden top

Wand: Small wand with triangle shaped brush

Formula: Vegan, gluten-free, paraben-free, fragrance-free, based on clay, non-toxic mascara

Performance and Reviews: Ecco Bella FlowerColor Mascara is your best friend if you need a soft and natural look. If you are looking for an everyday mascara, this must be your choice. It doesn’t add a lot of volumes or make your lashes very thick, but it comes with a mirror of its own that will help you do your makeup if you’re not at home or in front of a mirror. It’s not suitable for people with contact lens because after a long day it flakes and the small particles of mascara can get into your eyes. But if you have allergies, can’t wear regular mascara or just want a natural, non-toxic product, this is the one for you. It is perfect for your sensitive people, and you’ll forget soon about the irritated, red eyes.

PROS:
  • Water resistant
  • Easy to remove

CONS:
  • Can flake at the end of the day



Kjaer Weis Mascara

 

Packaging: Small package, modern tube

Wand: Short wand, big brush with plastic bristles focused on volumizing and thickening

Formula: Cupuacu butter, beeswax, castor oil to nourish and protect lashes, lavender water and rose oil; the product formed without synthetic polymers and parabens, non-toxic mascara

Performance and Reviews: Kjaer Weis Mascara’s formula has everything you ever dreamed for: Cupuacu butter, well known for its nourishing properties and moisture and castor oil, the one that gives you stronger and healthier lashes. Yes, this is one of the best natural mascara brands. More than this, it has great lavender and rose smell, and it’s non-toxic mascara. If you have short and thin lashes, this is a product that has to be on your shopping list. After adding one coat of mascara, you can see the thickness, darkness, and lengthening. It doesn’t give you any spider eyes and it does not run all over the face during the day. It is an efficient mascara; you don’t even need to put eyeliner on your eyes because it does an incredible job highlighting them. The product is not tested on animals and is gluten free and certified organic. The only problem about this product seems to be that it doesn’t separate lashes very well.

PROS:
  • Mascara for thin lashes
  • Thickening mascara
  • Great rose smell
  • Refillable
  • Doesn’t flake
  • Smudge proof mascara

CONS:
  • Doesn’t separate lashes very well


Mineral Mascara – All Natural

 

Packaging: Small tube with metallic top

Wand: Triangle shaped brush, small wand

Formula: Vegan, cruelty-free natural mascara, all natural organic, non-toxic mascara

Performance and Reviews: This might be one of the best all natural organic mascara. All reviews agreed to one thing: if you need volume, this is the mascara you have to purchase. The organic components give you an intense black color for your lashes that will last all day, even in wet periods. Because EVXO is eco-friendly, for this mascara they decided to use a reduced amount of plastic materials to design the product. Besides the plastic container, all the ingredients used for this product are vegan, cruelty-free and non-toxic.

PROS:
  • Separates lashes
  • Doesn’t clumps
  • Lasts all day
  • No smearing
  • Easy to take off
  • Volumizing mascara

CONS:
  • Not good for short lashes


Organic Cold Pressed Castor Oil – 100% Pure

 

Packaging: Transparent container with label on it and with matte silver top

Wand: Normal brush that can be used both for your lashes and eyebrows

Formula: Contains castor oil, a highly recommended oil for lashes, eyebrows, hair and skin

Performance and Reviews: If you struggle with small and rare lashes, this product will help you solve the problem. Castor oil is famous for its properties: hair grows faster and healthier, and it’s also very nutritious for your skin. By using this treatment, you will notice a huge change in no time. Your lashes will get thicker and stronger and so will your eyebrows. Because it is an antifungal agent, the castor oil won’t get your eyes irritated even if they are sensitive or if you wear contact lens. Also, don’t forget about the ingredients that castor oil contains: minerals, vitamins, Omega 6 and 9; it’s good for hair loss and rashes. So bye-bye, small and rare lashes, hello full and thick eyelashes!

PROS:
  • Thickening mascara
  • Mascara for thin lashes
  • Volumizing mascara
  • Strengthens your lashes
  • Easy to apply

CONS:
  • Dries slowly


Best Natural Looking Mascara

 

Shu Uemura Ultimate Natural Mascara

 

Packaging: Long black tube

Wand: Regular wand with standard brush

Formula: Waterproof

Performance and Reviews: We’re telling you, this is the best mascara for a natural look! You all know the line “Simple is better”? Well, sometimes a natural and very refined look might be the most eye-catching! If you don’t need a dramatic look and you just want to impress with your simplicity, this certainly is the best natural effect mascara. It will make your lashes look delicate, and it’s very suitable for a simple, day wear. Because it’s waterproof and it doesn’t clump, this natural looking mascara is the perfect choice for a long day at work. You will be charming all day, and it’s ideal for people with sensitive eyes.

PROS:
  • Waterproof
  • Smudge proof mascara
  • Doesn’t clump

CONS:
  • Weak volume


Best Cheap Natural Mascara

 

Physicians Formula Organic Wear 100% Natural Origin Jumbo Lash Mascara

 

Packaging: Green leaf bottle shape

Wand: Normal wand with fat brush and rubber bristles

Formula: No chemicals, synthetic preservatives-free, parabens-free, GMO’s-free, no artificial color, and fragrances, non-toxic mascara

Performance and Reviews: This mascara is the perfect pick for people with sensitive eyes because it is fragrance-free and it doesn’t have artificial color or parabens that can irritate and harm your eyes. Another important aspect about this mascara is that this product might be the best natural mascara for the money value. Let’s face it, we all like cheap products and all of us want to find the best one! However, if the price will convince you to buy it, you have also to think about this aspect: the only problem with this mascara is that if you have small eyes, it will be very tough for you to use the big fat wand and brush. We have to mention that after the second coat your lashes get clumpy and you’ll get the spider look.

PROS:
  • Best cheap natural mascara
  • Synthetic preservatives-free, parabens-free, GMO’s-free
  • Cheap
  • Perfect for sensitive eyes

CONS:
  • After the second coat, it flakes and clumps


Best Natural Mascara for Sensitive Eyes

 

Tarte Gifted Amazonian Clay Smart Mascara

 

Packaging: Wooden look-alike tube

Wand: Circular brush, decent size, natural bristles

Formula: A hybrid formula that is going to increase the lash up to 300%, with Amazonian clay and natural ingredients.

Performance and Reviews: Because of its natural ingredients and because it has no parabens, sulfates, phthalates, this mascara is the best natural mascara for sensitive eyes. The Amazonian clay is well known for its properties and will repair your lashes and make them healthier. This mascara is a very healthy product for lashes, and it also makes them look bigger and with a lot of volumes. All the reviews agreed on something: this mascara gives volume, health and makes lashes look longer and stronger. It’s the perfect choice for those who need a natural product that doesn’t clump or smudge.

PROS:
  • Easy to apply
  • Volumizing mascara
  • Thickening mascara
  • Mascara for thin lashes
  • Length

CONS:
  • Dries quickly


 

Best All Natural Waterproof Mascara

 

Tarte Lights, Camera, Splashes! Waterproof Mascara

 

Packaging: Unique purple package

Wand: Regular wand and brush

Formula: Without parabens or glue, mineral oils, cruelty-free

Performance and Reviews: “Tarte Lights, Camera, Splashes!” climbed very fast in the best all natural waterproof mascara top. The reason is very simple: not only that it lasts all day and that it won’t flake, but it also gives you long and curly lashes! If you like to emphasize your lashes, then this is the best natural waterproof mascara for you. Simple is always beautiful! And the effect given by this mascara is breathtaking: long and curly lashes, an eye-catching look. The only problem seems to be that this mascara has a wet formula and you’ll have to wait a little bit for it to get dry.

PROS:
  • No clumping
  • Waterproof
  • Lasts all day

CONS:
  • Wet formula


Best Natural Looking Brown Mascara

 

Ecco Bella Botanicals: Flower Color Mascara, Brown

 

Packaging: Small brown square tube with golden top

Wand: Small wand, triangle shaped brush

Formula: No parabens, no fragrance, vegan

Performance and Reviews: Few know about the effects of brown mascara. But all of them know this color it’s hard to find. Well, we’re telling you: this is the best natural looking brown mascara because it is PURE BROWN. Not brownish or black. Exactly how you wanted it! The other great thing about this mascara is that it is also proper for teenagers because it’s not very dramatic. Even if you’re not a student, we guarantee that this brown mascara will make you look younger. More than this, it won’t hurt your eyes or lashes because it is paraben-free and vegan and we guarantee that this is in the top for best all natural mascara brands.

PROS:
  • Doesn’t flake
  • Perfect for sensitive eyes
  • Water resistant

CONS:
  • Little volume


 

Best Natural Looking Mascara for Blondes

 

Aveda Earth Mascara

 

Packaging: Comes in a pale gray box with a gray small circular tube

Wand: Small to medium size, medium length brush

Formula: Natural, non-toxic

Performance and Reviews: Because it’s formula has non-toxic ingredients Aveda Earth Mascara it’s the perfect choice for those who struggle with sensitive eyes or need to wear contact lens every day. It is well known that you need to be more careful with the products you use if you have these problems. Also, this is the best natural looking mascara for blondes because it has a brown chocolate color that fits perfect with the color of your hair. Not only that it makes your lashes look natural, but it also makes them very thick. In the meantime, one of the problems seems to be that even if it is for everyday use, this product tends to flake. Because it is wet mascara, the curl of the lashes straightens out shortly after using.

PROS:
  • Excellent for sensitive eyes (doesn’t irritate them)
  • Doesn’t clump
  • Smudge proof mascara
  • Remove easily
  • Thickening mascara

CONS:
  • It doesn’t last too long


Best Conditioning Natural Mascara

 

Ere Perez – Organic Almond Oil Mascara


Packaging: Modern white glossy container with shiny gray brand inscription

Wand: Medium wand with triangle shaped brush, bendable brush

Formula: Beeswax, Palm kernel wax, soybean seed wax, sweet almond oil, palm oil, vitamin E, orange oil, lemon oil, bergamot oil

Performance and Reviews: Ere Perez – Organic Almond Oil Mascara uses a gentle formula, and it is the best conditioning natural mascara. It is waterproof; it will last on your lashes all day long. And no headaches caused by the clumping, smudging or bad smell. This mascara seems to have it all: natural ingredients, such as palm oil, palm kernel wax, soybean seed wax and vitamin E. When these are combined, the effect can be only brilliant. One of the problems that people often complained about is that this mascara is not easy to remove at all! On the other hand, Ere Perez recommends that you should clean this product with sweet almond oil. When talking about the effects of this mascara, you will notice that your lashes will have more volume, will be thicker, longer, and don’t forget, healthier and more resistant.

PROS:
  • Thickening mascara
  • Waterproof
  • Smudge proof mascara
  • Volumizing mascara
  • Great smell
  • Doesn’t clump

CONS:
  • Difficult to remove


 

Best Natural Hypoallergenic Mascara

 

Mineral Fusion Volumizing Mascara

 

Packaging Big silver color container with a cute red-purple brand inscription

Wand: Big wand with a densely bristled brush

Formula: Carnauba wax, candelilla wax, vegetable glycerin, vitamin E, Camellia sinensis leaf extract, aloe leaf juice, iron oxide; hypoallergenic, gluten-free, cruelty-free

Performance and Reviews: Sick of all those mascaras that cause you allergic reactions because you have sensitive skin and eyes? Well, this Mineral Fusion Volumizing Mascara should solve the problem. Reviews say that this is the best natural hypoallergenic mascara. And we surely do believe that after a close look at the list of ingredients: gluten free, vegetable glycerin, vitamin E, Camellia sinensis leaf extract, aloe leaf juice, etc. Impressive, right? Besides that, you’ll be amazed to see that this is smudge proof mascara, no small flakes of product around your eyes, no clumping and it’s very easy to apply.

PROS:
  • Smudge proof mascara
  • Doesn’t flake
  • Easy to apply
  • Not clumping


Best Natural Water Resistant Mascara

Pacifica Aquarian Gaze Water-Resistant Mascara (Abyss)

 

Packaging Normal size tube, cylinder shaped with light blue lines and gold brand inscription

Wand: Big fat brush with rubber bristles

Formula: Coconut Oil, Vitamin B, Kelp extract

Performance and Reviews: Look at those ingredients! This Pacifica Aquarian Gaze Water-Resistant Mascara contains coconut oil, an excellent product that will keep irritations away from your eyes. Vitamin B is vital, it regenerates your lashes and helps them grow faster and thicker. This product is a smudge proof mascara, very easy to remove and you’ll have the certainty that this will not give up on you during a long day at work. An interesting thing is a concept the manufacturer embraces: the impact on the environment. All their products boxes are 100% percent recyclable.

PROS:
  • Thickening mascara
  • Smudge proof mascara
  • Removes easily
  • Waterproof
  • Cruelty free
  • Vegan

CONS:
  • Doesn’t hold a curl for too long