Best Organic Mascara

There are so many mascara brands out there which suit everybody’s needs and wants. However, it’s important to know what mascara to buy to avoid damaging your lashes and also to protect your eyes from harmful products that some mascaras may contain. With these ideas, organic mascaras bring the best of both worlds. They provide length and volume to lashes, without harming them, and can also represent a way to treat your lashes, nourishing them with essential oils and vitamins.

What makes an organic mascara great?

Natural, organic ingredients are chosen above synthetic ingredients. Instead of using mineral oxides as pigments, most natural mascaras have clay based dyes which are harmless if they get in contact with eyes. All natural and organic mascaras must be free from preservatives and parabens. This means that the average shelf life of an organic mascara is less than 12 months. It’s also good to keep in mind that it’s very difficult to find organic waterproof mascaras because the chemical responsible for making the mascara smudge proof and waterproof is usually synthetic. This doesn’t mean that there aren’t any water-resistant mascaras out there which are also organic. They probably won’t be as good as the normal waterproof mascaras, but they will resist quite long on your lashes, without having to worry about flaking and smudging. To give you a better idea of what products you can choose, here is a list with the best organic and natural mascaras.

 

Top 5 Best Organic Mascara Reviews

Endlessly Beautiful Mascara

 

 

 

Packaging: environmentally friendly packaging, small, black tube with black cap and golden logo, the ingredient list is on the tube, the tube contains 0.25 fluid oz. of product.

Wand: synthetic hair bristle wand, densely packed

Formula: Water, Chamomile Hydrosol, Carnauba Wax, Mica (CI 77019), Coffee Powder, Rice Powder, Sunflower Seed Oil, Corn Starch, Lecithin, Tocopherol Acetate (Vitamin E), Origanum Vulgare Leaf Extract, Thymus Vulgaris Extract, Cinnamomum Zeylanicum Bark Extract, Rosmarinus Officinalis Flower Extract, Hydrastis Canadensis Root Extract, Grapefruit Seed Extract, Vanilla Planifolia; paraben free, cruelty free, gluten free, vegan

Performance and reviews: the first thing that strikes most of the users is the pleasant smell of this mascara. Even though the product smells like vanilla and a hint of coffee, it’s not irritating to the eyes. The main benefit of this mascara is that it doesn’t clump, and it applies surprisingly easy and evenly. The mascara comes with a guide on how to best use the product to make sure you use it well. The mascara dries quickly, and it is buildable so you can achieve a very bold look as well as a subtle, more natural look. Even though the formula is organic, the product is smudge proof and doesn’t flake, assuring your lashes look great throughout the day. On the down side, some may find that the tube is relatively small compared to regular mascara, but the producers say that the quantity is similar to that of an ordinary mascara tube. For those who like to put on several coats of mascara, the tube may not last as long. Also, the mascara is not waterproof. However, some people claimed to resist to tears.

PROS:

  • long wear
  • no clumping
  • smudge proof
  • vegan
  • cruelty-free
  • gluten free


Physicians Formula Organic Wear

 

 

 

Packaging: a light beige tube with a shiny, green, leaf-like cap; 0.26 oz.

Wand: short, silicone-like bristles

Formula: Orange Fruit Water*, Glycerin*, *Iron Oxides, Microcrystalline Cellulose, Glyceryl Stearate SE, Beeswax*, Jojoba Esters, Carnauba Wax*, Tapioca Starch*, Rice Extract*, Stearic Acid, Soybean Oil*, Olive Leaf Extract*, Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Extract*, Cucumber Fruit Extract*, Cellulose Gum, Glycerin, Magnesium Aluminum Silicate, Glyceryl Caprylate, Leuconostoc/Radish Root Ferment Filtrate May Contain: Titanium Dioxide;* Ingredients from Organic Farming; cruelty free, paraben free, 70% organic, vegan, GMO-free

Performance and reviews: for those who are on a limited budget but still want to avoid using regular mascaras, this mascara may be a go-to option. The ingredients of the mascara are 100% natural and 70% organic. Not only the mascara lengthens and gives volume but also acts as a treatment for lashes, promoting their growth. The texture of the mascara is light and feels very smooth, similar to a moisturizing effect. On the plus side, the mascara is easy to remove so you won’t damage your lashes by rubbing your eye with makeup remover. As good as this sounds, there are some downsides as well. For instance, the mascara dries slowly and smudges quite easily. As a consequence, the look may not last long throughout the day and may need some reapplying from time to time. Another minus is that the mascara is not waterproof and may contain gluten. Despite these, the product is ophthalmologically tested and hypoallergenic.

PROS:

  • hydrates the lashes
  • easy to remove
  • can be layered for a more dramatic effect
  • hypoallergenic
  • cruelty-free
  • vegan

CONS:

  • smudges easily
  • not waterproof



Pacifica Stellar Gaze & Strength Mascara Supernova

 

 

 

Packaging: a white tube with dark blue logo, white cap with cute, golden stars and patterns; 0.25 fl oz.

Wand: densely packed, synthetic bristles

Formula: Aqua, glycerin (vegetable), glyceryl stearate se, jojoba esters, tapioca starch, stearic acid (vegetable), carnauba wax, candelilla wax, arabic/acacia gum, acrylates, crosspolymer, potassium cetyl phosphate, microcrystalline cellulose (plant), coconut oil, panthenol (vitamin b), cellulose gum, gluconolactone, brown kelp extract, hydrolyzed rice protein, sodium benzoate, iron oxides c1 77499; cruelty free, vegan, paraben free

Performance and reviews: this mascara promises to give you length and volume to lashes with natural ingredients and no help from synthetic chemicals. This mascara even deals with stubborn, straight lashes, helping them curl. If a natural look is not your thing, then you can build the mascara for a thicker lash look without making them feel heavy. The main down sides, like most organic or natural mascara, concern smudging and lack of waterproof action. Some users experienced smudging right after application. If you accidentally touch your lashes the mascara transfers.

PROS:

  • easy to layer
  • provides volume and length to lashes
  • no clumping
  • no flaking

CONS:

  • smudges easily
  • not waterproof



Naturally Rooted Mascara 151

 

 

 

Packaging: a black tube with metallic blue logo, 0.26 oz.

Wand: full bristle brush

Formula: Water, Organic Chamomile, Beeswax, Glycerol, Organic Carnauba Wax, Organic Sunflower Oil, Stearic Acid, Rice Powder, Organic Lecithin, Shellac, Vitamin E, Sodium Hydroxide, Origanum Vulgare Leaf Extract. Cinnamonum Bark Extract, Organic Rosemary Leaf Extract, Organic Lavender Flower, Organic Golden Seal Root Extract, Organic Lemon Peel, Caprylyl Glycol, may contain natural dioxides & oxides; cruelty-free, paraben free, gluten free.

Performance and reviews: the fact that the majority of the ingredients have organic origins makes this mascara is suitable for sensitive eyes. Lack of harmful ingredients and dyes also contributes to the mascara’s nutritive effect on lashes. Also, the formula stays soft on lashes, so it doesn’t weigh them down. Also, the mascara doesn’t flake during the day, so you don’t have to worry about checking your makeup all the time. One or two coats, depending on your lashes, will provide length and full color, without clumping. However, if you tend to sweat easily, this mascara may not be your choice of preference since it smudges easily. Also, some customers experienced the mascara to be too dry to use.

PROS:

  • it leaves lashes soft
  • provides length in one coat
  • no flaking
  • no clumping

CONS:

  • mascara may seem dry
  • not waterproof

 



CHIC REPUBLIC Mascara

 

 

 

Packaging: black tube with black cap, white logo; 0.31 oz.

Wand: lash building brush

Formula: Water, Organic Chamomile, Beeswax, Glycerol, Organic Carnauba Wax, Organic Sunflower Oil, Stearic Acid, Rice Powder, Organic Lecithin, Shellac, Vitamin E, Sodium Hydroxide, Origanum Vulgare Leaf Extract, Cinnamonum Bark Extract, Organic Rosemary Leaf Extract, Organic Lavender Flower, Organic Golden Seal Root Extract, Organic Lemon Peel, Caprylyl Glycol, May Contain natural dioxides & Oxides; gluten free, paraben free, cruelty free.

Performance and reviews: if the normal mascara is irritating your eyes or you simply cannot stand the chemical smell, then maybe this product may suit you better. This mascara contains natural and organic ingredients which benefit your lashes. Aside from achieving long, fluttery lashes, your eyes won’t have to suffer from harmful compounds found in most non-natural mascaras. Because the formula is gentle on your lashes and eyes, it removes quickly and stays on great throughout the day. Like most organic mascaras, this brand isn’t water proof. On top of this, some users may find the formula too thick and may clump.

PROS:

  • it is easily removed
  • doesn’t flake
  • hypoallergenic

CONS:

  • mascara may clump
  • formula may seem thick

 



Best Organic Waterproof Mascara

100% Pure Fruit Pigmented Ultra Lengthening Mascara 1205

 

 

Packaging: stylish silver tube and cap with floral engraving and logo; 0.3 oz.

Wand: volume building wand

Formula: Organic Black Tea Leaf Extract *, Vitamin E, Honey Beeswax, Blackberry Extract, Blackcurrant Extract, Raspberry Extract, Hydrolyzed Oat Protein, Hydrolyzed Wheat Protein, Pantothenic Acid, Seaweed Powder Extract, Coconut Stearic Acid, Mica, Cocoa Butter, Pearl Powder, Rice Powder, Cocoa Powder, Powdered Coffee Beans), Lavender Honey, Oregano Extract, Thyme Extract, Rosemary Extract, Lavender Extract, Goldenseal Extract; *Certified Organic; 100% vegan, cruelty free, paraben free, gluten free

Performance and reviews: natural and waterproof? Yes, this formula promises to endure sweat and rain without the harsh chemicals present in regular waterproof mascaras. The mascara contains many plant extracts to assure your lashes stay healthy and at the same time it makes your lashes curls, gives them volume and length as well as withstanding the presence of water. All and all, the mascara is suitable for sensitive eyes and also contact lens wear. As great as this mascara sounds, there are some aspects you need to consider before purchasing the product. If your skin tends to be on the oily side, then maybe this product doesn’t suit you since you may experience flaking and smudging.

PROS:

  • waterproof
  • suitable for sensitive eyes
  • gives volume and length

CONS:

  • may smudge

 



Best Natural Organic Mascara

W3LL PEOPLE – Expressionist Mascara

 

 

Packaging: metallic, mat-gray tube and cap with black logo, 0.2 oz.

Wand: silicone-like bristle wand for volume

Formula: Water, Benzyl Alcohol, Cellulose, Beeswax*, Carnauba Wax*, Caster Isostearate, Beeswax Succinate, Dehydroacetic Acid, Geraniol, Glycerin, Glyceryl Stearate, Sunflower Seed Oil, Hydrogenated Palm Glycerides, Limonene, Sodium Hydroxide, Stearic Acid, tocopherol, Xanthan Gum, Vanilla**, Orange Oil**, [+/- CI 77499 (Iron Oxide)], * Ingredient from Organic Farming **Eco Certified; gluten free, paraben free, cruelty free.

Performance and reviews: the formula is guaranteed to separate and coat lashes to create the desired volume effect. The formula is very light weight so if you want to go all dramatic, then simply put on a second and even a third layer of mascara to achieve the desired effect. The product is great for those who are prone to irritation since the formula doesn’t flake and contains organic ingredients. Also, if you are on a low-end budget and just became interested in organic mascaras, then maybe this is the best product to start your journey into the world of organic makeup. On the down side, depending on your habits and skin type, your mascara may smudge a little more than expected. If you have an oily complexion or if you apply mascara right after you apply face cream, then you’re certain that the mascara will smudge, especially on lower lashes. You can avoid this by delaying the application of mascara, or you can put on some simple eyeshadow or face powder before coating your lashes with mascara.

PROS:

  • suitable for sensitive eyes
  • doesn’t clump
  • provides length and volume

CONS:

  • may smudge depending on skin type
  • not waterproof



Best Organic Mascara for Sensitive Eyes

Ecco Bella All Natural Mascara

 

 

Packaging: unique glass tube with golden logo and stylish, mat, gold cap; 0.38 oz. regular size; 0.14 oz. mini size.

Wand: length bristle brush

Formula: Purified water, carnauba wax, palmitic acid (from palm oil), clay, phenoxyethanol and iron oxides; gluten-free, paraben-free, cruelty-free, fragrance-free, vegan.

Performance and reviews: the most interesting aspect about this mascara is that the regular size bottle comes with an incorporated mirror, which makes it even more useful on the road. Apart from this, this mascara is probably the simplest one out there when it comes to ingredients. These bare, essential ingredients offer you lashes both volume and length, without fallout and no irritation. The mascara goes on very smooth and leaves a nice light coat on the lashes. There are some small inconveniences regarding this product. Similar to most organic and natural mascaras, depending on the skin type, they tend to smudge more or less. The mascara does withstand a certain degree of humidity but if you have runny eyes then maybe this product is not suitable for you.

PROS:

  • provides volume and length
  • no fallout

CONS:

  • may smudge